Picoult Overreaches and Misses on Genre and Message in House Rules
You have to hand it to Jodi Picoult in House Rules : she writes enough mystery around her characters to leave readers scratching their heads, wondering if they ought to sympathize with and stay with the characters through the entire book, or jump ship early because it seems so obvious where the book is headed. In House Rules, Jacob is an 18-year old with Asperger syndrome, raised by and living with his single mother Emma, carrying on a typical love/hate relationship with his 15-year old brother Theo. Obsession with the TV show CrimeBusters and crime scenes gets him into trouble when his social skills tutor and crush Jess ends up dead, and he steps in to lay out her corpse perfectly for the police to discover. Arrested for Jess’s murder, Jacob struggles to explain his involvement in Jess’s death to his family, the police, and the courts. A great deal of the novel is spent on Jacob’s thoughts, then showing him fail to clearly verbalize those thoughts during his court case. ...